I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
(5 ratings)
Store policies
Made from plant-based oils, it has 70% less saturated fat than butter.
Caters to diverse preferences with Original, Vegan, Light, Spray, and Stick varieties.
The official website offers customers detailed product information and a variety of recipes.
The brand is committed to the sustainable sourcing of its palm oil ingredients.
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$1 Off ICBINB! Salted Sticks at Albertsons
Offer applies to 16 oz Salted Sticks packs.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
26
used in the last hour
Used
40
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$1.50 Off ICBINB! Original at Walmart
Save on 15 oz Original Spread tubs today.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
17
used in the last hour
Used
50
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$2 Off ICBINB! Original Spray at Publix
Discount on 8 oz Original Spray bottles.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
16
used in the last hour
Used
56
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$1 Off ICBINB! Vegan Spread at Whole Foods
Enjoy savings on 15 oz Vegan Spread tubs.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
21
used in the last hour
Used
57
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$1.50 Off ICBINB! Garlic Spray at Meijer
Save on 8 oz Garlic Spray bottles now.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
25
used in the last hour
Used
61
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$1 Off ICBINB! Vegan Spread at Kroger
Enjoy savings on 15 oz Vegan Spread tubs.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
28
used in the last hour
Used
67
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$2 Off ICBINB! Light Spread at H-E-B
Discount on 15 oz Light Spread tubs.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
21
used in the last hour
Used
72
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$1.50 Off ICBINB! Original Spread at Costco
Save on 45 oz Original Spread tubs today.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
15
used in the last hour
Used
73
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$1.50 Off ICBINB! Olive Oil at Safeway
Offer valid on 15 oz Olive Oil Spread tubs.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
12
used in the last hour
Used
85
times
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter
Verified
$2 Off ICBINB! Light Spread at Target
Discount applies to 45 oz Light Spread tubs.
View offer on Benny
Expires
12/30/25
8
used in the last hour
Used
98
times
How It Works
STEP 1
Download Benny
Download the Benny app on iOS or Android. It’s free and just takes a minute.
STEP 2
Scan Your Receipt
Snap a photo of your receipt after shopping. Benny identifies eligible purchases matching the coupon.
STEP 3
Get Paid
Get cash back with the amount of the coupon directly to your Benny account in the same day.
Download Benny
Muscle Milk
Verified
$3 Off Muscle Milk Pro Series Protein Powder at Sam's Club
On Muscle Milk Pro Series Protein Powder.
Download Benny
Oatly
Verified
$3 Off Oatly Frozen Dessert at Publix
On Oatly Frozen Dessert.
Download Benny
Horizon Milk
Verified
$1.50 Off Horizon Organic Whole Milk at Walmart
On Horizon Organic Whole Milk.
Download Benny
Fairlife Milk
Verified
$3 Off Fairlife Chocolate 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk 14oz at Meijer
On Fairlife Chocolate 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk 14oz bottles.
Download Benny
Muscle Milk
Verified
$2.50 Off Muscle Milk Gainer Protein Powder at Meijer
On Muscle Milk Gainer Protein Powder.
Download Benny
Fairlife Milk
Verified
$3 Off Fairlife Chocolate 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk at Target
On Fairlife Chocolate 2% Ultra-Filtered Milk bottles.
Download Benny
Frequently Asked Questions
